Why You Keep Making the Same Mistakes in Love (And Yeah, I’ve Made Them Too)
Let me start with a confession.
I’ve been a psychologist for a long time. Decades. And in all those years, the question I hear most — usually in the first session, usually whispered like someone’s admitting to a crime — is this:
“Why am I so unlucky in love?”
People say it like the universe has it out for them. Like there’s some cosmic comedian writing jokes at their expense.
They watch their friends glide into happy relationships — you know the type, the ones who make it look effortless — and they wonder: what’s wrong with me?
Here’s the thing I’ve learned, sitting on this chair, across from hundreds of people just like you.
Luck has almost nothing to do with it.
Love isn’t a lottery. You don’t get a winning ticket or a losing one. If your love life feels like a series of train wrecks, it’s not bad fortune. It’s a pattern.
And patterns — unlike luck — can be broken.

The Invisible Suitcase (We All Have One)
Here’s something they don’t teach you in school: you walk into every relationship carrying luggage. Not the physical kind. The psychological kind.
Your attachment style. The scripts you learned about love when you were five years old. What “home” felt like.
I had a patient — let’s call her Maria — who kept dating men who were just out of reach. One was married (she didn’t know at first). One lived in another city. One was “processing his divorce” for three years.
Maria wasn’t unlucky. She grew up with a dad who loved her but was never there. Always traveling, always busy, always just out of reach.
So as an adult, that felt like home. The anxiety, the waiting, the hoping — that was familiar. The calm, present, boring guys? They felt wrong to her.
We call this repetition compulsion. Fancy term, simple idea: you keep choosing what you know, even when what you know hurts.
You aren’t cursed. You’re just following an old map.
The Spark Is a Liar (Sorry)
We are obsessed with the spark.
Movies, songs, rom-coms — they all tell you the same thing: when you meet The One, you’ll know. Butterflies. Stomach flips. Can’t breathe.
I’ve seen this belief destroy more good relationships than almost anything else.
Here’s the truth that no movie will tell you: that intense, dizzying spark is often not love. It’s anxiety.
Sometimes it’s a trauma bond. Sometimes it’s your nervous system recognizing an old pattern — someone who’s hot and cold, someone who keeps you guessing, someone who feels familiar because they’re unavailable.
And here’s the kicker: when you chase that spark, you walk right past the sturdy people. The ones who text back. Who show up on time. Who are kind and consistent and emotionally present.
Those people don’t make your heart race. They make you feel safe. And if you grew up in chaos, safety can feel boring.
I know. I’ve done it myself.

The Self-Worth Trap
There’s a direct line between how you see yourself and who you let into your bed (and your heart).
If you secretly believe you’re “too much” or “not enough” or fundamentally broken — you will tolerate people who treat you that way. Not because you’re stupid. Because it confirms what you already believe.
I had a patient — I’ll call him David — who was brilliant, kind, successful. But he kept dating women who criticized him. One told him he wasn’t ambitious enough. Another said he was “emotionally clumsy.” A third ghosted him after six months.
David wasn’t unlucky. He had a quiet voice in his head that said you don’t deserve someone who’s nice to you. So when a woman was warm and consistent, he got suspicious. What’s her angle? When someone was cold or critical, he felt at home.
You cannot invite someone into a house you wouldn’t want to live in yourself.
That sounds like a bumper sticker. But it’s true.
Stop Auditioning (No One’s Watching)
So many people walk into dating thinking they have to perform.
They hide their opinions. They stifle their weird hobbies. They pretend to be “easygoing” when they’re actually anxious. They say yes when they want to say no.
I get it. You want to be liked. We all do.
But here’s the problem with performing: it’s exhausting. You will eventually get tired. The mask will slip. And then what? The person who fell in love with the performance feels betrayed. Or worse — you realize they never knew you at all.
If you’re hiding who you are to get a partner, you aren’t finding love. You’re finding an audience.
And audiences eventually go home.
The scary thing — the thing no one wants to hear — is that real connection requires you to be seen. Warts. Weird laughs. Bad jokes. Emotional needs. All of it.
If they run? Good. They weren’t for you.

How to Actually Break the Cycle (What Works)
Okay. That was a lot. Let me give you something practical.
I tell my patients — and I try to tell myself — to stop treating dating like a “search and rescue mission” and start treating it like intentional observation.
Here’s what that looks like:
1. Audit your history.
Go back. Look at your last three or four relationships or situationships. Be honest. What do they have in common?
- Were they all emotionally unavailable?
- Did they all live far away?
- Were they all “working on themselves” (for years)?
- Did they all make you feel anxious?
Identifying the thread is the first step to pulling it loose.
2. Go on a date with someone “boring.”
I’m serious. Someone who texts back. Someone who makes plans. Someone who doesn’t keep you guessing. Give them two or three dates. See if a different kind of attraction — one based on respect and safety — starts to grow.
It might not. But it might. And if it does? That’s the real thing.
3. Use boundaries as a filter.
Early. Like, early early.
If someone cancels last minute without rescheduling? Data point.
If they make a dismissive comment about your feelings? Data point.
If they push a physical boundary “as a joke”? Data point.
The faster you say “no thanks” to people who don’t treat you well, the more room you make for someone who does.
FAQs (Short, Honest, No Fluff)
You’re not attracting them. You’re accepting them. Big difference. When you raise your standards and tighten your boundaries, the wrong people lose interest because they can’t manipulate you.
Probably part of it. Anxious people chase avoidants. Avoidants run from anxious people. It’s a dance as old as time. Learning your style is like getting a map of your own emotional reflexes.
One hundred percent yes. Being single isn’t a waiting room. It’s the foundation. Build something there.
Weeks? Months? A year? There’s no set timeline. But change happens in stages: first you notice the pattern, then you catch yourself in the act, then you choose differently. Be patient with yourself.
Sure. Timing, chance encounters, being in the right place — yeah, that stuff matters. But you create more surface area for luck by being the healthiest version of yourself. When you’re standing in clarity, you recognize a good thing when you see it.
Final Thought (From Someone Who’s Still Learning)
You are not cursed.
You are not broken.
You are just learning. And the lessons hurt because they’re trying to wake you up.
Stop waiting for your luck to change. Start changing the architecture of your choices.
You deserve the love you give away so freely.
Start by giving it to yourself.